Insurers
Every insurer we compare
Customer scores, how many claims are paid, how quickly, and the complaints each insurer gets. The same figures for all of them.

- Ashby & CoA mutual owned by its members since 1898; profits go back into lower premiums.8.4out of 10 from 1,082 reviews94% of claims paid11 days to pay, median0.4 complaints per 1,000from £26.10/month
- BrightwellA direct insurer that sells online only, with one plain policy and add-ons you pick yourself.8.1out of 10 from 859 reviews91% of claims paid9 days to pay, median0.6 complaints per 1,000from £25.05/month
- HarbourOne of the large household names, with a 24-hour claims line and a network of approved repairers.7.9out of 10 from 3,455 reviews89% of claims paid14 days to pay, median1.1 complaints per 1,000from £26.55/month
- KestrelA specialist in older and listed houses, with rebuild cost worked out by surveyors.7.6out of 10 from 350 reviews93% of claims paid16 days to pay, median0.8 complaints per 1,000from £27.95/month
- LowtherA broker-backed insurer for higher-value homes and contents, with a named claims handler.8.3out of 10 from 612 reviews95% of claims paid12 days to pay, median0.3 complaints per 1,000from £39.80/month
- mutuoA newer app-based insurer: monthly cover you can change or pause from your phone.8.6out of 10 from 2,720 reviews92% of claims paid6 days to pay, median0.5 complaints per 1,000from £27.45/month
- NorthfieldA supermarket-brand policy underwritten by a large insurer, with a loyalty discount.7.4out of 10 from 4,180 reviews87% of claims paid15 days to pay, median1.4 complaints per 1,000from £28.20/month
- OakesA regional insurer with its own claims team and an office you can visit.8.0out of 10 from 940 reviews92% of claims paid10 days to pay, median0.7 complaints per 1,000from £29.10/month
- PenroseCover for landlords and let properties, including rent guarantee.7.8out of 10 from 410 reviews90% of claims paid13 days to pay, median0.9 complaints per 1,000from £30.40/month
- quilt.Contents-first cover for renters and sharers, with flatmates on one policy.8.5out of 10 from 1,530 reviews93% of claims paid7 days to pay, median0.5 complaints per 1,000from £24.10/month
- RowanA green insurer that repairs before it replaces and offsets its claims.8.2out of 10 from 780 reviews91% of claims paid11 days to pay, median0.6 complaints per 1,000from £28.70/month